How can I taste your cake flavors?

You can order cake tasting packages to be picked up from any of our locations in NYC, DC or LA locations or have one shipped to your home. Our cake tasting package includes a 1" x 1" sample of each of the eight flavors available for cake orders. Each package is suitable for two people, and costs $40 ($42 to ship). The cost of the tasting can be applied as a credit towards the purchase of a tiered cake, should you decide to move forward.

  • Click here to arrange to pick up a tasting package at one of our NYC Milk Bar locations: Pick Up a Cake Tasting.
  • Click here to have a cake tasting shipped (in this case, there is a handling fee + FedEx overnight shipping fee): Ship a Cake Tasting.

Alternatively, casual in-house tastings may be scheduled with two weeks notice at the following locations: are held at our multi use classroom/event space in Williamsburg, Brooklyn, . Tasting appointments are available on Thursdays from 12pm-5pm in 45 minute blocks. If there is a date/time within that schedule that would work for you, please let us know and we will check our availability!